Redeemer Lutheran Church
1084 W. Bullard Ave.
Fresno, CA   93711
Phone: (559) 439-8500
Fax: (559) 439-8585
office@redeemerfresno.com

The Reverend Clarence Eisberg
Phone: (209) 725-9082
Cell:  (209) 631-3108
pastor@redeemerfresno.com

Worship ~ 8:30 a.m. & 10:00 a.m.
Family Ministries ~ 10:00 a.m.
Holy Communion ~ 2nd & 4th Sundays
www.lcms.org








The Reverend
Clarence Eisberg

March 9, 2008

“Cain: The Story of Alienation”
In Jesus Holy Name                 

This is the third message in our series: O.T. Challenges.  In Genesis chapters 1-3 we saw
Adam and Eve sharing a life of perfect love and harmony, with each other and with their
Creator.  All of creation existed in harmony with each other, until the slithering serpent
came into their world and caused them to doubt God’s goodness and love.

There was intimate friendship with God and each other.
Intimacy is the experience of knowing and feeling:
1)        acceptance
2)        reassured…..through pleasurable contact
3)        in harmony with God…. A sense of peace… an absence of fear and emptiness
4)        being in an expansive relationship over a period of time.

Adam and Eve lived in an intimate relationship with each other, with God and their world.  
The world and the relationships in which we now live are different.  Perfect love, harmony
and peace are things people in the world only hope to possess.  People are at war.  They
pollute their environment, throwing trash along the road side, dumping oil and chemicals
into the beautiful blue seas, and acid rain falls to the earth.  After the Chernobyl incident,
the soil is useless and death and disease claims the lives of adults and children. Our
problem is sin.

Our world, our society still seeks peace and harmony and intimacy but these are elusive.  
Instead, we have alienation and fear in our city streets, playgrounds and homes.  Human
beings experience separation from the knowledge of the goodness of God.  We have
become descendants of Cain.

The story of Cain and Abel may be familiar to you. (read Genesis 4:1-12)  The biblical
writer lets us know that Cain and God were on speaking terms.  Cain brought an offering
to the Lord, just as Abel did.  God, “looked with favor” on Abel’s offering but not on Cain’s.

Paul Bretscher in his book “Cain Come Home” writes: “We trust God to know what he is
doing when he gives gifts or withholds them according to His pleasure and wisdom.  In the
story of Cain and Abel, the point of God choosing to “look with favor” on one offering and
not the other is contrary to our natural notion of fairness.  No doubt Cain worked as hard
as Abel but God treats the brothers differently.”  

Why does God accept the one and not the other?

We are uncomfortable when we see unequal treatment between Cain and Abel.  In
Malachi 1:1-5 we read about God’s love for Jacob and his hatred for Esau.  Was not Esau
Jacob’s brother?  Yet Jacob I have loved; but Esau I have hated.”  The words seem so
unfair.  Especially when we think of the kind of person Jacob was.  He deceived his father
into giving him the blessing that should have gone to his older brother Esau. (Genesis 27)

Why does God bless one and not the other?  We ask questions like: “Why did God
harden Pharaoh’s heart and why should he choose Israel to be his people?”  Why does
God tell Rebecca the elder shall server the younger? Why did God choose the youngest
child of Jesse, David a teenager, to be the King of Israel replacing Jonathan the son of
Saul?  

We are people who “know good and evil” when we see it.  These are theological
questions for us.  Paul confronts the same question in Romans 9…”Why should God
speak the promise to Isaac and not Ishmael?”  The Jews are descendants of Isaac, the
Arabs are descendants of Ishmael.  

Our natural feelings, our knowledge of good and evil wants to call God “unfair”, “unjust”.  
Listen to Paul’s response in 9:14,16  “Can the potter do what he wants with his clay?”  
“Can the clay trust the potter?”  

Cain, by experience, feels that God is unjust, by not accepting his offering.  But let me ask
you a question first.  Do you think Adam and Eve told their boys about the Garden of
Eden?  Do you think Adam and Eve told their boys about how God forgave them by
shedding the blood of an animal?  I’m sure they did.

Now we do not know what was wrong with Cain’s offering….how large, how small.  We do
not know what was wrong in his heart about offering thanks to God. What we are seeing
here is an act of worship… an offering to God.  We know that God looked with favor on
Abel’s offering from the “first born of his flock”, but Cain’s offering did not receive God’s
favor.  Cain knew his offering was not acceptable.  He became jealous and angry. It isn’t
fair! Haven’t I worked as hard, if not harder than Abel? It’s not fair. Maybe he thought:  
“What good is it to pray and sacrifice to God if God treats me like this?”   

The Lord comes to Cain, I think in a helpful way; “Why are you angry?”  “Why is your face
down cast?”  Note the next verse…doesn’t it hint that Cain had knowledge of what was
right?  “If you do what is right, will you not be accepted?  But if you do no do what is right,
sin is crouching at your door; it desires to have you, but you must master it.”  (Genesis 4:
6-7)

The Lord intervenes for Cain.  Cain’s real enemy is not God, not Abel, but sin.  God warns
him…. “Don’t let your anger lead you to sin….Sin is crouching at your door, it desires to
have you.”   The problem is real for us too.

It reminds me of the story of two little boys about three and four years old who were doing
what three and four old boys do best: fighting with each other.  The battle escalated with
the older doing the taunting and the younger fighting for position.  Eventually, because he
couldn’t come up with anything better, the younger said, “I hate you!”  The older replied in
kind, “Not as much as I hate you.”

Realizing she had lost control, the mother resorted to a bit of bribery.  “Boys, you know we
don’t talk that way to each other. I’m not gong to take my two young men to McDonald’s as
long as they hate each other.”  Recognizing superior wisdom when he heard it, the four
year old capitulated, “I don’t really hat you.”  But the younger replied, “I’m not hungry.  I
still hate you!”  They are words of alienation.  

Like Cain, we are easily overpowered by our sense of injustice when we feel we are not
getting our fair share.  Joseph’s brothers resented what appeared to be favoritism on their
father’s part toward Joseph. (Genesis 37:4)  Jealousy and resentment was the root of
their sin, and it nearly ended, like Cain in the murder.

Cain acts as if he did not even hear God’s words.  God has also placed his law into our
hearts as well.  We have a conscience.  We know what is right and what is wrong. Too
which voice do we listen?  Cain invites his brother out into the field?  He has hatred for his
brother.  He murdered his brother.

The act is done.  The temptation became a sin. There is no turning back.  Abel is dead.  It
is God who opens the conversation with Cain… “Where is your brother?”  It was God who
re opened conversations with Adam and Eve in the Garden…  Cain shrugs his
shoulders… He lies.  “I don’t know. Am I my brother’s keeper?”  

God was not deceived by fig leaves.  He sees through Cain as well.  Abel’s tongue is
silent, but his blood is not. It cries to God from the earth.   He ought to collapse in tears,
as did Peter after his denial of the Jesus, when on trial at the house of the High Priest.  
Cain ought to confess the whole horror, thrown himself on God’s mercy… He does not.  
He retreats into self pity…. My punishment is more than I can bear…. Who ever finds me
will slay me.” Cain sees what is happening and he doesn’t like it.   

Cain is alienated from his family, from his earth, from God. He turns his back and walks
away from God.

I can not help but think of the two men who walked with Jesus for three years.  They saw
his miracles.  They saw him raise the dead.  They listened to Jesus tell about God’s love,
his offer of forgiveness.  

There came a time in a garden of olive trees, outside the walls of Jerusalem. One man
Judas betrayed Jesus for 30 pieces of silver.  The other man, Peter, followed Jesus into
the courtyard of the High Priest.  It was there that he too betrayed Jesus, he lied, saying:
“I do not know the man…” in order to save his own skin.  

Their self reflection was different.  Both admitted their action was wrong.  Peter wept
bitterly, but Judas, well, for reasons we do not know, could not grasp to his own heart the
very words he heard Jesus say to the paralytic:  “Your sins are forgiven.”  

Cain could have collapsed and asked for God’s mercy and forgiveness…he in stead
turned his back on God and walked away.  Judas went out and hanged himself.  But we
find Peter at the cross.

Phillip Hiller, the hymn writer, in 1767 wrote these words:
“All my sins have been forgiven. God is merciful to me.
My account is closed for ever, Jesus Christ has paid it all.
Shed His blood my sin to cover, paid the price to save My soul.  
There is now no condemnation, I am fully reconciled;
All my sins have been forgiven, God is merciful to me.”    
(Hymns for the Living Church)  291

At the cross the crowds shouted words of hate.  Jesus never hated back.  He called on his
Father to forgive them.  At the cross we can find intimate friendship with God and each
other restored.  

Intimacy is the experience of knowing and feeling:
acceptance – because of Jesus we have been accepted by God.
we are reassured…of his love...through the joy of worship and prayer.
His word tells   us we can trust the potter who made us.
At the foot of the cross we find harmony with God…. A sense of peace…
an absence of fear of death because Jesus rose from the grave

Now, living under God’s grace, filled with His Spirit we learn to live in an expansive
relationship over a period of time, imitating Jesus.